Cavaliers vs. Pacers Game 4: Betting Odds, Key Players, and Prop Bets for NBA Playoffs

Spotlight on Cavaliers vs. Pacers: What’s Driving the Game 4 Betting Lines?

There’s something almost jarring about seeing the Cavaliers tagged as five-point favorites on the Pacers’ home court, especially with the series hanging in the balance. Indiana has turned its arena into a scoring jungle, running up the points at home through clutch moments and fast-paced offense. Yet, sportsbooks leaned in favor of Cleveland—banking on talent, playoff resiliency, and a few game-altering matchups.

For bettors, the prop market provided its own rabbit holes. Tyrese Haliburton’s three-point line was set at 2.5 made shots, but the under was favored (-145 odds). That’s a subtle tip that sharps see Haliburton facing a tighter Cavaliers’ perimeter defense or simply not having his best shooting night. Haliburton’s game has been volatile through the playoffs—sometimes a human highlight reel, other times struggling to find his groove. Do you trust the numbers or take the risk on an Indiana shooter having a bounce-back game?

The other popular line was the OVER on total points. Cleveland seems to have rediscovered its offensive rhythm, especially with Donovan Mitchell at the controls. Through this postseason, Mitchell has dropped an eye-opening 31.3 points per game—no fluke, considering his knack for finding buckets when his team needs it most.

Players and Matchups Shaping Game 4

Indiana’s home form is impossible to ignore. Myles Turner, in particular, has become a force in the paint, bullying defenders and getting to the rim at will. The Pacers feed off his energy and inside scoring, using him to draw in defenders and then spraying the ball out to open shooters. Mix in a crowd that loves nothing more than raining noise down on the visiting Cavaliers, and you have a genuine home-court headache for Cleveland.

But the Cavaliers aren’t arriving empty-handed. With improved health, they’ve brought both defensive intensity and versatile scoring. Evan Mobley’s defense stands out—his ability to disrupt shots and alter drives has made a huge dent in Indiana’s usual game plan. If Mobley can stay out of foul trouble and hold down the paint, Cleveland’s odds look even stronger.

Another question is whether Indiana’s guards—especially Haliburton—can break free from Cleveland’s relentless perimeter defenders. The Cavaliers have learned to cut off passing lanes and force the Pacers’ shooters into tough, low-percentage looks. If Indiana can’t stretch the floor, it could be a long night.

This matchup is as much about health and momentum as it is about star power. Cleveland’s lineup finally looks close to full strength compared to their battered roster earlier in the year. That boost is huge for their confidence, and with the promise of home-court advantage later in the series, you can bet they want to seize control while Indiana’s back is against the wall.

So as Game 4 tips off, bettors are eyeing every stat, trend, and ankle tape. Will Mitchell’s hot streak keep rolling? Can Turner keep dominating the paint? Are the oddsmakers onto something fading Haliburton’s threes? The only thing that’s certain is the stakes just keep getting higher.